Destroying Gender Stereotypes Among Child Abuse Offenders
As a male who has worked with youth most of my adult life, I am well aware of the fact that as a man, I am monitored much more strongly when I work with students than my female counter parts are. I have to take extra caution to make sure I am never put in a questionable situation. Much of this is based on the paranoia society feels over the threat of sexual abuse among children--and some of it is warranted but most of it is not. The media does not help this paranoia with the amount of crime shows like CSI and Law and Order which often depict extreme abuse cases which more than likely are caused by men.
However, this paranoia directed at men who work with youth is unfair. The statistical research in the area of child abuse tells a more accurate story. The fact is, if the only thing you are worried about is sexual abuse, then it is true that as a group men are more likely to commit those kinds of crimes. However, in every other form of child abuse--physical, emotional, & neglect--it is more likely as a group that women will be found guilty.
Here is an excerpt from the F.A.C.T. website on child abuse:
In reality, violence against children is perpetrated by both men and women. We can see from the US that the actual incidence of violence, with the exception of sexual abuse, is higher from women and mothers than from men and fathers. In addition, moderate or severe injury is more often the result of abuse from women than from men. The death of children from violence is largely a crime of women.
So, in reality, the unfair stereotype against men working with children needs to be challenged. Once again, if the only thing we care about is whether or not our children are being sexually abused--then by all means continue to be bias toward men working with students. However, I believe all forms of abuse are serious and a threat to the health of our children. For that reason, we need to change our stereotypes and hold men AND WOMEN to the same safety standards. We need to be just as careful and cautious about the women who are working with our students as we are the men.
Once again as someone who has worked in schools, churches, camps, & daycares for most of my adult life--I have found that as a whole, women are more likely to yell, shout, scream, and demonstrate anger with their students than men. I do not say this as a way to point fingers or to flip the blame--I say it only to make my point. It is unfair to stereotype men who work with youth and to monitor them any more closely than you would a woman.
In any case, my final conclusion is this: I believe we need to make every effort to protect the physical and emotional safety of our children and so we need do need to hold those of us who work with children accountable and to put procedures in place that protect children--BUT that accountability needs to be EQUALLY applied to men and women and those procedures need to be enforced equally among men and women. A person who works with children should be singled out solely on the basis of his or her gender.
In any case, my final conclusion is this: I believe we need to make every effort to protect the physical and emotional safety of our children and so we need do need to hold those of us who work with children accountable and to put procedures in place that protect children--BUT that accountability needs to be EQUALLY applied to men and women and those procedures need to be enforced equally among men and women. A person who works with children should be singled out solely on the basis of his or her gender.
